Overcoming Challenges around IT/OT Convergence on the Factory Floor

A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by our Manufacturing Technology Insights Advisory Board.

MES & Data Systems at Roeslein & Associates

Overcoming Challenges around IT/OT Convergence on the Factory Floor

Jonathan Saunders

The convergence of operational technology (OT) and information technology (IT) presents a transformative opportunity for industrial sectors, yet it's not without its challenges. Some of these main challenges are integrating security systems across modern and legacy architectures, managing the disparity between OT and IT technologies, the skillset requirements for support teams, and democratizing automation for future workforces.

OT devices, integral to factory automation, differ significantly from IT systems, particularly in terms of logic processors and user interfaces. These devices, which are often part of industrial control systems (ICS), were not originally designed for remote access, complicating network security and maintenance. ICS networks typically use different protocols like EthernetIP and ModbusTCP, and play multifunctional roles in operations, which now extend to securing data for MES/SCADA systems.

A considerable portion of industrial equipment, especially in packaging and material handling, is equipped with industrial PLCs (programmable logic controllers). These PLCs, serving as control processing brains, execute logic functions based on signals from various devices. Understanding PLC class methods, whether synchronous or asynchronous, is crucial for OT technicians to ensure operational transactions are executed as designed, previously without consideration for data security.

Some of the challenges in OT/IT convergence include bridging the gap in device communication technologies, addressing LAN and cybersecurity issues, scalability in data collection/processing, and lifecycle management. Factors like device authentication, industrial hardware technology gaps, operating system maintenance, and monitoring network activities are pivotal in the successful convergence of projects.

Internally, companies stand to gain substantially from OT/IT convergence, with benefits including increased operational efficiency, enhanced data analysis and decision-making, cost savings, improved product quality, and innovation. It also leads to robust security protocols, better asset management, employee empowerment, and improved supply chain and inventory management.

"OT devices, integral to factory automation, differ significantly from IT systems, particularly in terms of logic processors and user interfaces."

The adoption of disruptive technologies is a critical aspect of this convergence. This shift will alter manufacturing processes, demanding changes in data management, analytics, supply chain management, workforce skills, cybersecurity, and infrastructure. It necessitates strategic planning and investment. For instance, automation and robotics, driven by advanced IT systems, will predictably take over many manual tasks, impacting manufacturing workflows. The influx of data from IT integration into factory settings will revolutionize how data is managed, requiring advanced analytics and AI for process optimization. Similarly, the convergence will enhance supply chain management, demanding logistics and inventory strategy adaptations.

The workforce must adapt to these technological shifts, transitioning from manual operations to more tech-focused tasks, for example. This change calls for significant training and redefining job roles. Cybersecurity becomes paramount as interconnected factories face increased cyber threats, requiring robust measures to protect sensitive data.

Moreover, advanced technologies will facilitate more precise quality control and product customization, demanding more flexible and adaptable production lines. The need for significant upgrades or replacements in factory infrastructure to support these new technologies is inevitable.

To summarize, the best OT/IT convergence practices involve the strategic integration of OT and IT. This integration should enhance operational efficiency, decision-making, and innovation through disruptive technologies like automation and AI. Critical components include robust data management, enhanced cybersecurity, workforce development, compliance with standards, and continuous improvement. This approach can substantially elevate a company's productivity and competitive edge, making it crucial for addressing factory floor challenges inherent in such initiatives.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.